Online Backup compared
We compare online backup services that automatically back up a Windows PC or Mac to the cloud. Scores cover backup scope, how long older versions are kept, number of computers, restore options, price, private encryption keys, data location, ease of use and contract terms. The yardstick is the cheapest personal plan that can back up one computer with 1 TB of data. Every score is based on a public source with a check date; prices are for customers in the United States.
- Rank 1:
88.0 / 100
Households with several computers that also want a Windows system image in the cloud.
from $6.99 / month
- Rank 2:
83.5 / 100
Single computers with lots of data, including external drives, that need a simple full backup.
from $8.25 / month
- Rank 3:
66.0 / 100
People who want cloud storage and folder backup in one plan.
from $8.33 / month
All services compared
- Rank 1
IDrive Personal
Free planOnline backup for any number of computers and mobile devices in one account, priced by storage (from 5 TB).
Details on IDrive Personal
Scores by area
- Features 100.0
- Value for money 60.0
- Privacy & security 80.0
- Ease of use 100.0
- Fairness & support 100.0
Strengths
- Any number of computers; price depends on storage
- Files deleted from the computer stay until you clean them up yourself
- Permanent free plan with 10 GB
- 24/7 chat and phone support, per provider
Weaknesses
- Introductory price applies to the first year only
- System image backup to the cloud on Windows only
- Rank 2
Online backup with no data cap per computer, a choice of data regions and restores on a mailed USB drive.
Details on Backblaze Computer Backup
Scores by area
- Features 77.5
- Value for money 66.7
- Privacy & security 90.0
- Ease of use 100.0
- Fairness & support 100.0
Strengths
- No data cap per computer, external drives included
- One year of version history at no extra cost
- Full refund within 30 days on annual and two-year plans
Weaknesses
- Each computer needs its own license
- No system image backup
- Rank 3
pCloud Backup
Free planBackup feature in pCloud Drive that continuously copies selected folders to pCloud storage, with a choice of EU or US data region.
Details on pCloud Backup
Scores by area
- Features 27.5
- Value for money 80.0
- Privacy & security 76.7
- Ease of use 100.0
- Fairness & support 100.0
Strengths
- EU or US data region selectable at sign-up
- Free plan and monthly billing
- Phone, email and contact form
Weaknesses
- Selected folders only; external drives and system images not described
- Trash and versions kept 60 days, longer only with a paid add-on
- Rank 4
Online backup for one computer with unlimited storage, phone support and courier recovery for an extra fee.
Details on Carbonite Safe
Scores by area
- Features 55.0
- Value for money 43.3
- Privacy & security 63.3
- Ease of use 100.0
- Fairness & support 100.0
Strengths
- Unlimited storage for one computer
- Phone support and a 30-day money-back guarantee
- Courier recovery available for an extra fee
Weaknesses
- Basic plan excludes external drives
- Deleted files are removed from the backup after 30 days
- Two-step verification by text or phone call only
- Rank 5
End-to-end encrypted online backup for unlimited devices that keeps deleted files and older versions with no fixed time limit.
Details on SpiderOak One Backup
Scores by area
- Features 82.5
- Value for money 46.7
- Privacy & security 56.7
- Ease of use 50.0
- Fairness & support 25.0
Strengths
- Encrypted on the device; only the user holds the keys
- No fixed limit on versions; deleted files are not purged automatically
- Unlimited devices on Windows, macOS and Linux
Weaknesses
- No iOS or Android apps
- Current term generally non-refundable
- Support by email or ticket only
- Rank 6
Backup app with system images, cloning and malware protection; cloud storage from the Advanced plan, 1 TB in Premium.
Details on Acronis True Image
Scores by area
- Features 50.0
- Value for money 33.3
- Privacy & security 66.7
- Ease of use 100.0
- Fairness & support 50.0
Strengths
- System images can be replicated to Acronis Cloud
- Phone, email and chat support, per provider
Weaknesses
- Plan covers 1 computer; no monthly billing
- Default retention for cloud backups not documented
- Rank 7
Arq 7 backup app for Windows and Mac with 1 TB of provider-managed cloud storage for up to 5 computers in the Arq Premium plan.
Details on Arq Premium
Scores by area
- Features 57.5
- Value for money 53.3
- Privacy & security 43.3
- Ease of use 50.0
- Fairness & support 50.0
Strengths
- Up to 5 computers in one subscription
- Encrypted with your own password before upload
- Keeps backups of external drives even if they are never reconnected
Weaknesses
- Only 1 TB included; each extra GB costs more
- No iOS or Android apps; email support only
Scores by area
| Rank | Service | Features | Value for money | Privacy & security | Ease of use | Fairness & support | Score | Price from |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | IDrive Personal | 100.0 | 60.0 | 80.0 | 100.0 | 100.0 | 88.0 | from $6.99 / month |
| 2 | Backblaze Computer Backup | 77.5 | 66.7 | 90.0 | 100.0 | 100.0 | 83.5 | from $8.25 / month |
| 3 | pCloud Backup | 27.5 | 80.0 | 76.7 | 100.0 | 100.0 | 66.0 | from $8.33 / month |
| 4 | Carbonite Safe | 55.0 | 43.3 | 63.3 | 100.0 | 100.0 | 65.6 | from $6.00 / month |
| 5 | SpiderOak One Backup | 82.5 | 46.7 | 56.7 | 50.0 | 25.0 | 58.3 | from $12.42 / month |
| 6 | Acronis True Image | 50.0 | 33.3 | 66.7 | 100.0 | 50.0 | 55.0 | from $10.42 / month |
| 7 | Arq Premium | 57.5 | 53.3 | 43.3 | 50.0 | 50.0 | 51.9 | from $5.83 / month |
Criteria and weights
Every score relies on a source. Group score = average of its criteria, total = weighted sum (0–100).
With online backup, what matters most is whether everything is there when you need it: what gets backed up, how long older versions are kept and how you get your data back. Features therefore count 35% instead of 30%. After setup, backup apps mostly run unnoticed in the background, so ease of use counts 10% instead of 15%.
Features Weight: 35 %
Backup scope
- 10: image of the entire system drive to the cloud, plus file backup
- 7: files on internal and external drives, all or freely selectable, without a system image to the cloud
- 4: only certain folders, or no external drives
- 0: no automatic backup, or not verified
Retention
- 10: with no time limit while the plan is active, or at least 1 year
- 7: 90 days to under 1 year
- 4: 30 to 89 days
- 0: under 30 days, or not documented
Computers per plan
- 10: 5 or more, or unlimited
- 7: 2 to 4
- 4: 1 computer
- 0: not verified
Restore options
- 10: app or browser, plus drive shipping within the market
- 6: in the app and in the browser
- 3: only one of these ways
- 0: not documented
Value for money Weight: 20 %
Price per year
- 10: up to $70 per year
- 7: up to $100 per year
- 4: up to $150 per year
- 0: more than $150 per year, or not verified
Monthly billing
- 10: up to $8 per month
- 7: up to $10 per month
- 4: up to $14 per month
- 0: more than $14, no monthly billing, or not verified
Free to try
- 10: permanent free plan with cloud backup
- 6: free trial of at least 14 days
- 3: shorter free trial
- 0: no free option, or not verified
Privacy & security Weight: 20 %
Private encryption key
- 10: on by default for all backups
- 7: optional for all backups
- 3: only for part of the data, or as a paid add-on
- 0: not available, or not verified
Data location
- 10: country stated and selectable for personal customers
- 7: country stated for personal customers, not selectable
- 3: only a general or indirect statement
- 0: no storage location stated for personal customers
Two-factor sign-in
- 10: authenticator app, security key, passkey or approval on a trusted device
- 5: SMS or email code only
- 0: no two-factor sign-in, or not verified
Ease of use Weight: 10 %
Language
- 10: app and help pages
- 5: only one of the two
- 0: neither, or not verified
Mobile access
- 10: iOS and Android
- 5: only one of the two systems
- 0: no app with access to the backup, or not verified
Fairness & support Weight: 15 %
Cancellation and refunds
- 10: online cancellation and such a period of at least 14 days
- 5: online cancellation, refunds only where required by law or at the provider's discretion
- 0: online cancellation not verified
Support
- 10: chat or phone
- 5: email or ticket only
- 0: help pages or community only, or not verified
Frequently asked questions
What is the difference between online backup and cloud storage?
Cloud storage keeps selected folders in sync across devices; if you delete a file, it usually disappears from the cloud too. Online backup copies a computer's data on a schedule or continuously and keeps older versions separately. That way you can recover files you deleted by mistake or that were encrypted by malware, as long as the retention period has not run out.
Is an online backup enough on its own?
A common rule of thumb is the 3-2-1 rule: three copies of your data, on two different types of media, with one copy off-site. Online backup covers the off-site copy. An additional backup to an external drive is usually faster to restore from, because large amounts of data do not have to be downloaded first.
What is a private encryption key, and what happens if I lose it?
With a private key, your data is encrypted on your computer, and the provider cannot read it without that key. If you lose it, the provider usually cannot decrypt the backup either. Keep the key somewhere other than the computer itself, for example in a password manager.
Why do you score retention?
Many problems are noticed late, such as a file deleted by mistake or an external drive that has not been connected for a long time. With some services, older versions and deleted files are also removed from the backup after a fixed period. We score the period that applies at no extra cost.
How long does the first backup take?
The first full backup can take days or weeks for large amounts of data, depending on your connection's upload speed. After that, usually only changed files are transferred. Some providers let you send in or receive your data on a physical drive; whether that is available in your country is up to the provider.