Search Engines compared

Last reviewed: · 9 services rated

A search engine searches the web and shows a list of links for your query. We score search engines against published criteria, with emphasis on what happens to your searches, how many ads appear, which search types and filters are available, and whether the provider discloses where its results come from. Every score links to a source and a check date. This version does not measure result quality.

  1. Rank 1:

    DuckDuckGo

    94.5 / 100

    For people who want free search without a profile and the option to turn ads off themselves.

    free

  2. Rank 2:

    Kagi

    80.8 / 100

    For people willing to pay for ad-free search with their own filters and settings.

    from $5.00 / month

  3. Rank 3:

    Brave Search

    79.8 / 100

    For people who want search with its own index and AI answers they can turn off.

    free

All services compared

  1. Rank 5

    Mojeek

    Free plan

    UK search engine with its own crawler and index, no cookies by default and no stored IP addresses.

    72.3 / 100
    free
    Visit site (Mojeek)
    Details on Mojeek

    Scores by area

    Features (25 %)55.0
    Value for money (20 %)50.0
    Privacy & security (25 %)100.0
    Ease of use (15 %)90.0
    Fairness & support (15 %)66.7

    Best suited for: For people who want search with its own index, no profile and no cookies.

    Strengths

    • No IP addresses stored; logs deleted after 90 days
    • Ad partners receive only the query and a country code
    • Results summary off by default

    Weaknesses

    • Ads cannot be turned off
    • Only web, images and news as search types

    Details on Mojeek →

  2. Rank 7

    Microsoft Bing

    Free plan

    Microsoft's search engine with its own index, the default search in Edge; no account needed.

    Details on Microsoft Bing

    Scores by area

    Features (25 %)85.0
    Value for money (20 %)50.0
    Privacy & security (25 %)16.7
    Ease of use (15 %)40.0
    Fairness & support (15 %)83.3

    Best suited for: For Edge users who want search with its own index and published ranking factors.

    Strengths

    • Own index; ranking factors and the role of payments described
    • All five search types
    • Interface, help and privacy statement in English

    Weaknesses

    • No retention period stated for searches
    • Ads cannot be turned off
    • No verified way to turn off AI answers

    Details on Microsoft Bing →

  3. Rank 9

    Startpage

    Free plan

    Search engine from Startpage BV that, per the provider, deletes IP addresses with every search and builds no search profiles.

    42.7 / 100
    free
    Visit site (Startpage)
    Details on Startpage

    Scores by area

    Features (25 %)50.0
    Value for money (20 %)50.0
    Privacy & security (25 %)66.7
    Ease of use (15 %)23.3
    Fairness & support (15 %)0.0

    Best suited for: For people who want to search without a profile and open websites through a proxy.

    Strengths

    • Per the provider, IP addresses are deleted with every search
    • No search profile, no targeted ads
    • Image, video, news and maps search

    Weaknesses

    • Website blocks our requests; many details not verified
    • Turning off ads not verified

    Details on Startpage →

Scores by area

Rank Service Features
25 %
Value for money
20 %
Privacy & security
25 %
Ease of use
15 %
Fairness & support
15 %
Score Price from
1 DuckDuckGo 100.085.0100.0100.083.3 94.5 free
2 Kagi 85.060.090.0100.066.7 80.8 from $5.00 / month
3 Brave Search 85.070.0100.080.050.0 79.8 free
4 Ecosia 85.050.056.783.3100.0 72.9 free
5 Mojeek 55.050.0100.090.066.7 72.3 free
6 Google Suche 100.050.026.773.383.3 65.2 free
7 Microsoft Bing 85.050.016.740.083.3 53.9 free
8 Yahoo Search 55.050.016.756.750.0 43.9 free
9 Startpage 50.050.066.723.30.0 42.7 free

Prices in US dollars before sales tax, as listed by the provider for the US. Prices may change; promotional prices may differ.

Criteria and weights

Every score relies on a source. Group score = average of its criteria, total = weighted sum (0–100).

Privacy counts 25 instead of 20 %, features 25 instead of 30 %. Searches reveal a lot about interests, health and plans, and what the provider does with them sets search engines clearly apart. We do not measure result quality, and the remaining features are more alike.

Features Weight: 25 %

Search types

For which of web, images, videos, news and maps does the search engine offer its own search on its website (tab or selector), regardless of where the results come from?

  • 10: All five types
  • 7: Four types
  • 4: Three types
  • 2: One or two types
  • 0: Not verified

Filters and search operators

Which of these four options does the provider document: a time-range filter, choice of the country or language of results, an adjustable filter for explicit content (SafeSearch), and search operators for at least exact phrases and searching within one website?

  • 10: All four
  • 7: Three of the four
  • 4: Two of the four
  • 2: One of the four
  • 0: None, or not verified

Value for money Weight: 20 %

Cost of use

Can the web search be used for free permanently, and if not, what is the regular monthly price of the cheapest plan with unlimited searches with annual billing (monthly billing if there is no annual option)?

  • 10: Permanently free with no search limit
  • 7: Permanently free with a search limit that renews regularly
  • 4: Paid plan only, unlimited searches up to $5.00 per month
  • 2: Paid plan only, unlimited searches up to $10.00 per month
  • 1: Paid plan only, unlimited searches over $10.00 per month, or with a search limit only
  • 0: Not verified

Ads in results

With the rated use (see cost of use), does the search engine show ads among or above the results, and can they be turned off?

  • 10: No ads, per the provider
  • 7: Ads, but they can be turned off for free in the settings
  • 4: Ads, ad-free only with a paid plan
  • 0: Ads that cannot be turned off, or not verified

Privacy & security Weight: 25 %

Retention of searches

Per the privacy policy, how long does the provider keep searches together with the IP address or a cookie, device or account identifier before deleting them or irreversibly anonymizing them? We rate use without an account, or, where an account is required, use with an account under default settings.

  • 10: Not stored together with an IP address or identifier
  • 7: 6 months or less
  • 4: 18 months or less
  • 1: Longer than 18 months, or no period stated
  • 0: Not verified

Profiling and personalized ads

Are results or ads personalized using a profile built from past searches, browsing or the provider's other services, and can you prevent this? Preferences you set yourself (for example preferred or hidden websites) do not count as a profile.

  • 10: No profile-based personalization (ads based on the current search and approximate location at most)
  • 7: Personalization only after explicit opt-in, off by default
  • 4: Personalization on by default, but it can be fully turned off
  • 0: Personalization that cannot be turned off, or not verified

Sharing with third parties

Per the privacy policy, does the provider share the IP address or identifiers linked to searches with third parties, such as results or advertising partners (processors acting on its instructions excluded)?

  • 10: No sharing of IP address or identifiers; partners receive the search query at most
  • 5: Shared only truncated or pseudonymized, with partners that may not use the data for their own purposes, per the provider
  • 0: Shared for the partners' own purposes, or not verified

Ease of use Weight: 15 %

Set as default search

In which of these six setups can the search engine be set as the default search, per the browser or search provider (built-in option, official extension, official app or instructions): Chrome, Firefox, Safari and Edge on a computer, Chrome on Android phones, Safari on iPhone?

  • 10: All six
  • 7: Four or five
  • 4: Two or three
  • 2: One
  • 0: Not verified

Market language

Are the search interface, help pages and privacy policy available in the market language (US: English, DE: German)?

  • 10: Interface, help pages and privacy policy in the market language
  • 5: Interface in the market language, but help pages or privacy policy missing
  • 0: No interface in the market language, or not verified

Control over AI answers

Can you decide for yourself whether an AI-generated answer or summary appears above the results?

  • 10: AI answers on request only, can be turned off permanently in the settings, or no AI answers per the provider
  • 5: Can be hidden per search only (for example via a filter or tab)
  • 0: Shown with no way to turn them off, or not verified

Fairness & support Weight: 15 %

Where results come from

Does the provider publicly disclose where its web results come from (its own search index, partners such as Bing or Google, or both), and does it name the partners?

  • 10: Source disclosed, partners named, or own index only
  • 5: General statement only, without naming partners
  • 0: No statement, or not verified

How results are ranked

Does the provider publicly describe the main factors it uses to rank unpaid results, and state whether and how payments affect that order?

  • 10: Main factors described, plus a statement on the effect of payments
  • 5: Only one of the two
  • 0: No statement, or not verified

Contact with the provider

How can users of the search engine reach the provider's staff?

  • 10: Email, contact form, live chat or phone answered by staff
  • 5: Only a feedback tool without replies, help pages or a forum
  • 0: Not verified

Frequently asked questions

Where do a search engine's results come from?

Only a few companies run a large search index of their own, a searchable copy of the web. Many search engines show results from a partner such as Bing or Google, in full or in part, often combined with their own data and interface. We check whether the provider discloses where its results come from.

How can I spot ads in search results?

Ads often appear at the very top and carry labels such as "Ad" or "Sponsored." Scammers sometimes buy ads that imitate well-known brands. Check the web address before you click, and for banks or stores, type the address you know directly into your browser.

What do search engines store about me?

It depends on the provider. Some keep searches together with your IP address or account for months and use them for personalized results and ads; others do not store them with an identifier. European data protection authorities consider six months the reasonable maximum in principle. The provider's privacy policy is what counts.

How do I change the default search in my browser?

In Chrome, Firefox and Edge, pick the search engine under "Search engine" or "Search" in the settings; if it is not listed, you can often add it from the provider's website or with an extension. Safari offers a fixed list only; other search engines work there through extensions.

Why don't you rate result quality?

How good results are depends on the query, language, location and timing. Individual samples would hardly carry over to you and would be hard to verify. This version only rates information that can be backed by public sources.

Related categories