Authenticator Apps compared
An authenticator app generates the one-time codes that add a second step to signing in to many services. We score apps built mainly for this purpose against published criteria: backup and switching devices, encryption, protection on the device, platforms, and import and export. Every score links to a source and a check date. Code features built into password managers are covered in our password manager category.
- Rank 1:
100.0 / 100
People who want encrypted sync across phones and computers and an easy way to switch apps later.
free
- Rank 2:
95.0 / 100
People who want an app on phone and computer, with optional end-to-end encrypted sync.
free
- Rank 3:
91.0 / 100
People who want to fill in codes on the computer through a browser extension.
free
All services compared
- Rank 1
Ente Auth
Free planOpen-source authenticator for iOS, Android, Windows, macOS, Linux and the web, with end-to-end encrypted sync or use without an account.
Details on Ente Auth
Scores by area
- Features 100.0
- Value for money 100.0
- Privacy & security 100.0
- Ease of use 100.0
- Fairness & support 100.0
Strengths
- End-to-end encrypted sync; offline mode without an account
- Apps for mobile, desktop and the web
- Imports from 2FAS, Aegis, Bitwarden, Google Authenticator and others
- Cure53 audit published in 2025
Weaknesses
- Sync and cloud backup require an Ente account with an email address
- Rank 2
Proton Authenticator
Free planOpen-source authenticator from Proton for iOS, Android, Windows, macOS and Linux, usable without an account; sync with a Proton account.
Details on Proton Authenticator
Scores by area
- Features 93.3
- Value for money 100.0
- Privacy & security 90.0
- Ease of use 100.0
- Fairness & support 100.0
Strengths
- No account, email or phone number needed
- End-to-end encrypted sync with a Proton account
- Imports from Google Authenticator, 2FAS, Aegis, Ente and others
Weaknesses
- No counter-based codes (HOTP), only TOTP and Steam
- No published third-party audit of the app yet
- Rank 3
2FAS Auth
Free planOpen-source authenticator for iOS and Android with a browser extension, iCloud or Google Drive backup and no account.
Details on 2FAS Auth
Scores by area
- Features 100.0
- Value for money 100.0
- Privacy & security 80.0
- Ease of use 100.0
- Fairness & support 80.0
Strengths
- Browser extension that requests codes from the phone
- Automatic backup through iCloud or Google Drive
- TOTP, HOTP and Steam with adjustable algorithm
Weaknesses
- Backup protected with a password of your own only after you set one
- Help only through help pages, Discord and GitHub; no general support email
- Rank 4
Aegis Authenticator
Free planOpen-source authenticator for Android with an encrypted vault, automatic backups to a folder of your choice and many import options.
Details on Aegis Authenticator
Scores by area
- Features 76.7
- Value for money 100.0
- Privacy & security 90.0
- Ease of use 100.0
- Fairness & support 100.0
Strengths
- Vault encrypted with AES-256-GCM, unlock with password or biometrics
- Automatic encrypted backups to a location of your choice
- Imports from about ten other apps
Weaknesses
- Android only, no iOS or desktop app
- Rank 5
Bitwarden Authenticator
Free planStandalone authenticator from Bitwarden for iOS and Android, usable without an account; optional sync with the Bitwarden password manager.
Details on Bitwarden Authenticator
Scores by area
- Features 83.3
- Value for money 100.0
- Privacy & security 60.0
- Ease of use 100.0
- Fairness & support 100.0
Strengths
- No Bitwarden account needed
- Imports from Google Authenticator, 2FAS, LastPass, Raivo and Aegis
- Export as JSON or CSV
Weaknesses
- No desktop app
- Google Play lists data shared with third parties (app info and performance)
- Rank 6
FreeOTP
Free planOpen-source authenticator from Red Hat for iOS and Android with TOTP and HOTP and adjustable algorithm.
Details on FreeOTP
Scores by area
- Features 90.0
- Value for money 100.0
- Privacy & security 62.5
- Ease of use 50.0
- Fairness & support 80.0
Strengths
- TOTP and HOTP, SHA-1 to SHA-512, 6 or 8 digits
- No data collected per App Store and Google Play
- Keys stored in Android Keystore or Apple Keychain
Weaknesses
- No import from other apps
- No app-wide lock; only individual tokens can require device authentication
- Rank 7
Google Authenticator
Free planAuthenticator from Google for iOS and Android; sync through your Google Account or use without an account.
Details on Google Authenticator
Scores by area
- Features 76.7
- Value for money 100.0
- Privacy & security 47.5
- Ease of use 50.0
- Fairness & support 60.0
Strengths
- Automatic sync through your Google Account
- Usable without an account; Google Play: no data shared with third parties
- Time-based and counter-based codes
Weaknesses
- Sync not end-to-end encrypted; Google encrypts in transit and at rest
- Import only from Google Authenticator; export only as QR codes
- Source code of the current app not public
- Rank 8
Twilio Authy
Free planAuthenticator from Twilio for iOS and Android with password-encrypted cloud backup and sync across devices, tied to a phone number.
Details on Twilio Authy
Scores by area
- Features 73.3
- Value for money 100.0
- Privacy & security 47.5
- Ease of use 50.0
- Fairness & support 50.0
Strengths
- Cloud backup encrypted with a password of your own
- Sync across several devices
- Supports 8-digit codes
Weaknesses
- Account tied to a phone number
- No import or export described
- No desktop app
- Rank 9
Duo Mobile
Free planAuthenticator from Cisco Duo for iOS and Android, mainly for Duo accounts, also for personal accounts at other services.
Details on Duo Mobile
Scores by area
- Features 73.3
- Value for money 100.0
- Privacy & security 50.0
- Ease of use 50.0
- Fairness & support 15.0
Strengths
- No sign-up needed for personal accounts
- Duo Restore backup encrypted with a recovery password
- Google Play: no data shared with third parties
Weaknesses
- No export of third-party accounts and no import
- No support from Duo for personal accounts
- Rank 10
Microsoft Authenticator
Free planAuthenticator from Microsoft for iOS and Android with sign-in approvals for Microsoft accounts and cloud backup of codes.
Details on Microsoft Authenticator
Scores by area
- Features 73.3
- Value for money 100.0
- Privacy & security 37.5
- Ease of use 50.0
- Fairness & support 30.0
Strengths
- Cloud backup through iCloud (iOS) or a Microsoft account (Android)
- App Lock on by default with device PIN or biometrics
Weaknesses
- Backup key held by a Microsoft key service, no password of your own
- No import or export of codes described
- Google Play lists location and app activity shared with third parties
Scores by area
| Rank | Service | Features | Value for money | Privacy & security | Ease of use | Fairness & support | Score | Price from |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Ente Auth | 100.0 | 100.0 | 100.0 | 100.0 | 100.0 | 100.0 | free |
| 2 | Proton Authenticator | 93.3 | 100.0 | 90.0 | 100.0 | 100.0 | 95.0 | free |
| 3 | 2FAS Auth | 100.0 | 100.0 | 80.0 | 100.0 | 80.0 | 91.0 | free |
| 4 | Aegis Authenticator | 76.7 | 100.0 | 90.0 | 100.0 | 100.0 | 90.0 | free |
| 5 | Bitwarden Authenticator | 83.3 | 100.0 | 60.0 | 100.0 | 100.0 | 83.0 | free |
| 6 | FreeOTP | 90.0 | 100.0 | 62.5 | 50.0 | 80.0 | 75.3 | free |
| 7 | Google Authenticator | 76.7 | 100.0 | 47.5 | 50.0 | 60.0 | 63.8 | free |
| 8 | Twilio Authy | 73.3 | 100.0 | 47.5 | 50.0 | 50.0 | 61.2 | free |
| 9 | Duo Mobile | 73.3 | 100.0 | 50.0 | 50.0 | 15.0 | 56.7 | free |
| 10 | Microsoft Authenticator | 73.3 | 100.0 | 37.5 | 50.0 | 30.0 | 55.2 | free |
Criteria and weights
Every score relies on a source. Group score = average of its criteria, total = weighted sum (0–100).
Almost all authenticator apps are free, so value counts 10% instead of 20%. An app like this holds the keys to your accounts, so privacy and security count 30% instead of 20%.
Features Weight: 30 %
Backup and device change
- 10: Automatic backup or sync (own service, system cloud, or a folder or cloud storage of your choice) that restores all accounts on a new device
- 6: Manually created backup file only, which can be restored in the app
- 3: Direct transfer to another device only (for example via QR code), no backup
- 0: No backup or transfer, or not verified
Platforms
- 10: iOS and Android, plus a desktop app or browser extension
- 7: iOS and Android
- 3: Only one of the two mobile platforms (with or without desktop)
- 0: Not verified
Supported code types
- 10: TOTP and HOTP, with algorithm, digits and time period adjustable or read from the QR code
- 8: TOTP only, with algorithm, digits and time period adjustable or read from the QR code
- 6: TOTP and HOTP with default values
- 5: TOTP only with default values, or other values not verified
- 0: Not verified
Value for money Weight: 10 %
Free use
- 10: Full feature set permanently free and without ads
- 6: Codes free, but backup, sync or more devices paid only, or a one-time purchase up to 5.00
- 3: Free only with ads or a limit on the number of accounts, or paid only by subscription or a one-time purchase over 5.00
- 0: Not verified
Privacy & security Weight: 30 %
Backup encryption
- 10: All backup and sync options encrypted this way by default
- 6: Encrypted this way only once turned on, or for some options only, or no backup feature (the keys never leave the device)
- 3: Encrypted only by the provider or cloud service, which can decrypt the data
- 0: Unencrypted, or not verified
Protection on the device
- 10: App lock and encrypted storage verified
- 6: App lock, encrypted storage not verified
- 3: Encrypted storage verified, no app lock
- 0: Neither, or not verified
Source code and third-party audit
- 10: Public source code and a third-party audit with a public report within the last 24 months
- 6: One of the two
- 3: Source code only partly public, or public audit report older than 24 months
- 0: None of these, or not verified
Data minimization and tracking
- 10: Usable without an account (an account is needed for sync at most), with neither tracking nor data shared with third parties disclosed
- 6: Account with an email address, or a platform account, required, or tracking or data shared with third parties disclosed
- 3: Phone number required, or an account required together with tracking or data shared with third parties
- 0: Not verified
Ease of use Weight: 15 %
Import from other apps
- 10: Import from at least two other apps
- 5: Import from one other app, or only from a generic file (such as a list of otpauth URIs)
- 0: One by one via QR code or key only, or not verified
Language
- 10: App and help pages
- 5: App only
- 0: No app interface in the market language, or not verified
Fairness & support Weight: 15 %
Export and switching
- 10: Export of all accounts as a file in an open or documented format (encrypted or unencrypted)
- 6: Export of all accounts only as QR code(s) to scan in another app
- 3: Export one account at a time only (show key or QR code)
- 0: No export, or not verified
Customer support
- 10: Staff reachable by email, form (possibly with a chatbot), live chat or phone
- 6: Public forum or public issue tracker only
- 3: Help pages only
- 0: Not verified
Frequently asked questions
How does an authenticator app work?
When you turn on two-factor sign-in, the service shows a QR code that contains a secret key. The app stores it and combines it with the current time to calculate a new code every 30 seconds (TOTP). When you sign in, you enter the current code in addition to your password. The app does not need an internet connection for this.
What happens if I lose my phone?
Without a backup, the keys are lost with the device, and you can only get back into each account with that service's recovery codes or its support team. Store these codes safely when you set up two-factor sign-in, and use the app's backup feature, ideally encrypted. If you can, erase the lost device remotely.
Are app codes safer than codes sent by text message?
Usually, yes: text message codes can be intercepted, for example through a SIM swap, while app codes cannot. App codes still do not protect you from fake sign-in pages where you type in the code yourself. Passkeys and security keys based on the FIDO standard resist this kind of phishing.
Authenticator app or password manager?
Many password managers can also generate one-time codes. That is convenient, but it keeps your password and your second factor in one place. A separate authenticator app, ideally on a different device from the one you sign in with, keeps the two factors apart. We rate password managers in a separate category.
How do I switch to another authenticator app?
Export the accounts from your current app as a file or batch QR code and import them into the new one. Then check for each account that the new app produces valid codes before you delete the old app. Delete any unencrypted export file right after the import.