Email Providers compared

Last reviewed: · 7 services rated

Your inbox holds bills, contracts and the reset links for almost every password you have. We compare consumer email providers using publicly verifiable information: storage, custom domains, ads, encryption, where data is stored and contract terms. We rate the free plan and the cheapest paid plan that adds storage or removes ads. This version does not measure spam filtering or deliverability.

  1. Rank 1:

    Proton Mail

    81.4 / 100

    People who want encryption and Swiss privacy law and can do without IMAP on the free plan.

    from $3.99 / month (billed annually)

  2. Rank 2:

    iCloud Mail

    80.3 / 100

    People who use an iPhone, iPad or Mac and want a low-cost, ad-free mailbox with their own domain.

    from $0.99 / month

  3. Rank 3:

    Fastmail

    72.4 / 100

    People who want an ad-free mailbox with their own domain and work with standard mail apps.

    from $5.00 / month (billed annually)

All services compared

  1. Rank 1

    Proton Mail

    Free plan

    Encrypted email from Proton AG (Switzerland), end-to-end encrypted between Proton users, on Proton's own servers in Switzerland.

    81.4 / 100
    from $3.99 / month (billed annually)
    Visit site (Proton Mail)
    Details on Proton Mail

    Scores by area

    Features (25 %)86.7
    Value for money (20 %)50.0
    Privacy & security (25 %)100.0
    Ease of use (15 %)65.0
    Fairness & support (15 %)100.0

    Best suited for: People who want encryption and Swiss privacy law and can do without IMAP on the free plan.

    Strengths

    • End-to-end encryption between Proton accounts by default
    • Own servers in Switzerland (per the provider)
    • Mail Plus includes a custom domain and 10 addresses
    • 30-day refund when you buy directly

    Weaknesses

    • Free plan limited to 1 GB of storage
    • Mail apps only through Proton Mail Bridge, paid plans only

    Details on Proton Mail →

  2. Rank 2

    iCloud Mail

    Free plan

    Apple's email service, built into iPhone, iPad and Mac; iCloud+ adds custom domains and Hide My Email.

    80.3 / 100
    from $0.99 / month
    Visit site (iCloud Mail)
    Details on iCloud Mail

    Scores by area

    Features (25 %)100.0
    Value for money (20 %)85.0
    Privacy & security (25 %)60.0
    Ease of use (15 %)75.0
    Fairness & support (15 %)80.0

    Best suited for: People who use an iPhone, iPad or Mac and want a low-cost, ad-free mailbox with their own domain.

    Strengths

    • iCloud+ from $0.99 per month with 50 GB
    • Up to five custom domains with iCloud+
    • IMAP and SMTP for any mail app

    Weaknesses

    • No end-to-end encryption for Mail, even with Advanced Data Protection
    • No Android app
    • No storage location stated

    Details on iCloud Mail →

  3. Rank 3

    Paid email service from Fastmail Pty Ltd (Australia) with no ads, apps for all major platforms and a choice of EU or US data storage.

    72.4 / 100
    from $5.00 / month (billed annually)
    Visit site (Fastmail)
    Details on Fastmail

    Scores by area

    Features (25 %)76.7
    Value for money (20 %)20.0
    Privacy & security (25 %)76.7
    Ease of use (15 %)100.0
    Fairness & support (15 %)100.0

    Best suited for: People who want an ad-free mailbox with their own domain and work with standard mail apps.

    Strengths

    • Individual plan with 50 GB for mail and a custom domain
    • Apps for Windows, macOS, Linux, iOS and Android
    • Choice of EU or US data residency
    • 30-day free trial

    Weaknesses

    • No free plan
    • No end-to-end encryption in Fastmail's own apps
    • Number of extra addresses not stated

    Details on Fastmail →

  4. Rank 4

    Tuta Mail

    Free plan

    Encrypted email from Tutao GmbH (Hanover, Germany) that also encrypts subject lines and stores data in Germany.

    71.8 / 100
    free
    Visit site (Tuta Mail)
    Details on Tuta Mail

    Scores by area

    Features (25 %)93.3
    Value for money (20 %)20.0
    Privacy & security (25 %)100.0
    Ease of use (15 %)50.0
    Fairness & support (15 %)80.0

    Best suited for: People who want full encryption and are happy to use Tuta's own apps instead of other mail apps.

    Strengths

    • End-to-end encryption including subject lines and attachments
    • Servers in Germany (per the provider)
    • Revolutionary includes 20 GB, 15 addresses and 3 custom domains
    • Apps for all major platforms

    Weaknesses

    • No IMAP, so no Thunderbird, Outlook or Apple Mail
    • Free plan limited to 1 GB
    • Prices listed in euros

    Details on Tuta Mail →

  5. Rank 5

    Outlook.com

    Free plan

    Microsoft's free email service; Microsoft 365 Basic removes ads and raises mailbox storage to 100 GB.

    71.3 / 100
    from $1.67 / month (billed annually)
    Visit site (Outlook.com)
    Details on Outlook.com

    Scores by area

    Features (25 %)43.3
    Value for money (20 %)90.0
    Privacy & security (25 %)50.0
    Ease of use (15 %)100.0
    Fairness & support (15 %)100.0

    Best suited for: People who use Windows or Microsoft 365 and want a low-cost, ad-free mailbox.

    Strengths

    • 15 GB of free email storage
    • Microsoft 365 Basic: ad-free, 100 GB mailbox, $19.99 per year
    • Apps for Windows, iOS and Android; IMAP on the free plan

    Weaknesses

    • Ads on the free plan
    • No end-to-end encryption found on the rated plans
    • No fixed storage location stated

    Details on Outlook.com →

  6. Rank 6

    Yahoo Mail

    Free plan

    Free email from Yahoo with 20 GB of storage; Yahoo Mail Plus removes ads and adds 200 GB and disposable addresses.

    64.6 / 100
    from $5.00 / month
    Visit site (Yahoo Mail)
    Details on Yahoo Mail

    Scores by area

    Features (25 %)66.7
    Value for money (20 %)70.0
    Privacy & security (25 %)36.7
    Ease of use (15 %)85.0
    Fairness & support (15 %)80.0

    Best suited for: People who want a lot of free storage and disposable addresses and accept ads on the free plan.

    Strengths

    • 20 GB of free storage
    • Mail Plus: ad-free, 200 GB, up to 500 disposable addresses
    • 14-day free trial of Mail Plus

    Weaknesses

    • Business email analyzed for ad profiles unless you opt out
    • No end-to-end encryption found
    • No custom domain mentioned for Mail Plus

    Details on Yahoo Mail →

  7. Rank 7

    Gmail

    Free plan

    Google's free email service with 15 GB of storage shared with Google Drive and Google Photos; more storage through Google One.

    50.3 / 100
    from $9.99 / month
    Visit site (Gmail)
    Details on Gmail

    Scores by area

    Features (25 %)43.3
    Value for money (20 %)50.0
    Privacy & security (25 %)36.7
    Ease of use (15 %)85.0
    Fairness & support (15 %)50.0

    Best suited for: People who want a free mailbox with plenty of storage and already use Google services.

    Strengths

    • 15 GB free, shared with Drive and Photos
    • IMAP always on for personal accounts
    • Gmail apps for Android, iPhone and iPad

    Weaknesses

    • Ads in the inbox, no ad-free plan stated
    • No custom domain found for personal accounts
    • S/MIME encryption only for work and school accounts

    Details on Gmail →

Scores by area

Rank Service Features
25 %
Value for money
20 %
Privacy & security
25 %
Ease of use
15 %
Fairness & support
15 %
Score Price from
1 Proton Mail 86.750.0100.065.0100.0 81.4 from $3.99 / month (billed annually)
2 iCloud Mail 100.085.060.075.080.0 80.3 from $0.99 / month
3 Fastmail 76.720.076.7100.0100.0 72.4 from $5.00 / month (billed annually)
4 Tuta Mail 93.320.0100.050.080.0 71.8 free
5 Outlook.com 43.390.050.0100.0100.0 71.3 from $1.67 / month (billed annually)
6 Yahoo Mail 66.770.036.785.080.0 64.6 from $5.00 / month
7 Gmail 43.350.036.785.050.0 50.3 from $9.99 / month

Prices in US dollars before sales tax, as listed by the provider for the US. Prices may change; promotional prices may differ.

Criteria and weights

Every score relies on a source. Group score = average of its criteria, total = weighted sum (0–100).

Privacy and security count 25 instead of 20 %, features 25 instead of 30 %. Your inbox carries a lot of personal data and the recovery of other accounts, so whether a provider uses email for ads, how it encrypts mail and where it stores it carries more weight.

Features Weight: 25 %

Storage on the paid plan

How much email storage does the cheapest paid plan include, per the provider (total amount if storage is shared)?

  • 10: 50 GB or more
  • 8: 20 to 49 GB
  • 6: 10 to 19 GB
  • 4: 2 to 9 GB
  • 2: less than 2 GB
  • 0: not verified

Custom domain

Can you use your own domain (e.g. name@yourfamily.com) with the mailbox?

  • 10: included in the cheapest paid plan
  • 5: only on a pricier plan or as a paid add-on
  • 0: not offered or not verified

Extra addresses and aliases

How many extra addresses or aliases (including disposable or masked addresses) does the cheapest paid plan include, per the provider?

  • 10: 10 or more, or unlimited
  • 6: 3 to 9
  • 3: 1 or 2, plus addressing only (name+tag@), or number not stated
  • 0: none or not verified

Value for money Weight: 20 %

Free plan

Is there a permanently free plan, and how much email storage does it include, per the provider?

  • 10: free plan with 15 GB or more
  • 7: free plan with 5 to 14 GB
  • 4: free plan with 1 to 4 GB
  • 2: free plan with less than 1 GB
  • 0: no free plan or not verified

Price of the cheapest paid plan

What does the cheapest paid plan that adds storage or removes ads cost per month on the cheapest term of up to 12 months (regular price, no introductory discount)?

  • 10: up to 1.50 per month
  • 8: up to 3.00 per month
  • 6: up to 4.50 per month
  • 4: up to 6.00 per month
  • 2: more than 6.00 per month
  • 0: no paid plan or price not verified

Privacy & security Weight: 25 %

Ads and ad profiling

Does the provider show ads in the mailbox, is there an ad-free plan, and does it analyze email for ad profiles, per its privacy policy?

  • 10: no ads on any plan
  • 7: ads on the free plan, ad-free paid plan, email content not used for ads per the provider
  • 5: ads on the free plan, ad-free paid plan, email analyzed for ad profiles only with opt-in consent
  • 3: ads with no ad-free plan, or email analyzed for ad profiles without prior opt-in
  • 0: not verified

Encryption

What encryption does the provider itself offer on the rated plans, beyond transport encryption (TLS)?

  • 10: end-to-end encryption between users of the service by default, stored email unreadable to the provider
  • 6: optional end-to-end encryption of its own (e.g. PGP in webmail) or mailbox encryption the user can turn on
  • 3: only transport encryption (TLS) documented; end-to-end only with third-party apps or certificates
  • 0: not verified

Data location

Does the provider state the country or countries where mailbox data is stored?

  • 10: country or countries of storage named
  • 5: only a general statement that data may be processed in several or other countries
  • 0: no information or not verified

Ease of use Weight: 15 %

Own apps

Besides webmail, does the provider offer its own apps for iOS, Android and at least one desktop operating system?

  • 10: webmail and own apps for iOS, Android and desktop
  • 7: webmail and own apps for iOS and Android
  • 5: webmail and own apps for only some of these platforms
  • 3: webmail only (third-party apps can be used)
  • 0: not verified

Access from mail apps (IMAP)

Can the mailbox be used with any mail app via IMAP and SMTP, and on which plans?

  • 10: IMAP and SMTP directly, including on the free plan or the cheapest plan
  • 6: IMAP and SMTP directly, but only on paid plans
  • 3: only through a helper app from the provider, paid plans only
  • 0: no IMAP or not verified

Fairness & support Weight: 15 %

Term and cancellation

What is the shortest term or prepayment period of the cheapest paid plan, and can you cancel it online?

  • 10: cancel monthly or no fixed term, cancel online
  • 6: shortest term or prepayment 12 months
  • 3: minimum term over 12 months, or no online cancellation documented
  • 0: not verified

Trial and refund

Can you try the paid plan for free or cancel it with a refund, per the terms (free trial, money-back period, refund of unused credit)?

  • 10: free trial or money-back period of at least 30 days, or refund of unused credit
  • 6: 14 to 29 days (including a statutory right of withdrawal stated in the terms)
  • 3: fewer than 14 days
  • 0: no trial or refund, or not verified

Frequently asked questions

What does end-to-end encryption mean for email?

With end-to-end encryption, only the sender and the recipient can read a message, not the provider. It usually works automatically only between users of the same service, or with PGP or S/MIME on both sides. Depending on the method, subject lines, senders and recipients often stay visible. Transport encryption (TLS) only protects the path between servers.

Why do you rate ads in the inbox?

Free mailboxes are often paid for by ads. Some providers analyze incoming email from businesses to build interest profiles; others rule that out. We rate what providers say about this in their plan descriptions and privacy policies.

What is IMAP, and why does it matter?

IMAP is an open standard that lets mail apps such as Thunderbird, Apple Mail or Outlook access your mailbox. It lets you choose your app freely and makes it easier to take your email with you if you switch providers. Providers with full end-to-end encryption often offer IMAP only through a helper app, or not at all.

What does a custom domain give me?

With a custom domain, your address doesn't belong to the email provider. If you switch providers, you keep the address by pointing the domain to the new service. You usually buy the domain itself separately from a domain registrar.

What should I check before switching email providers?

Check whether you can bring your old email over via IMAP or an export feature, and whether the new provider offers an import tool. Update your address with banks, stores and agencies step by step, and set up forwarding in the old mailbox while it is still active. Some providers delete free mailboxes that go unused for a long time.

Related categories