How we rank

Every NetMedals ranking follows the same rules. This page explains which criteria count, how much they weigh and how points become a position.

Principles

  • US market: We score prices, availability and terms as they apply to customers in the United States.
  • Sourced, not claimed: Every score relies on a publicly available source, such as a pricing page, terms, a privacy policy or a published audit report. Without a source, the criterion gets 0 points and is marked "not verified". If a provider blocks automated access, we do not work around it; we use other official pages of the provider or a reputable third-party source, marked "third-party source". If a source is blocked or unreachable when we re-check, the last verified value stays, with its check date, until its check period ends, for every service alike.
  • Calculated, not set: Positions follow from the points. Nobody moves positions by hand.
  • What does not count: whether we earn a commission and how much, whether a product is owned by us, requests or payments from providers, and brand popularity.

Which services we include

For each category we include the widely used services available in the US, plus services with a distinctive feature (for example open source code). Whether a provider has an affiliate program plays no role; at least five services per category. Suggestions for missing services are welcome.

Five criteria groups

Each category has 8 to 12 criteria in five groups. Default weights:

GroupWeightExamples
Features30 %Core features of the category, platforms, limits of the free plan.
Value for money20 %Cheapest sensible plan with monthly and annual billing, price after promotions end.
Privacy & security20 %Company seat and server locations, encryption, two-factor sign-in, independent audits, data sharing.
Ease of use15 %Setup, apps, accessibility, language support.
Fairness & support15 %Online cancellation, contract terms, refund rules, support, price transparency.

A category may adjust the weights if an area matters more there (for example privacy for VPN services). The weights and the reason are shown on that category page.

From points to positions

  1. Each criterion gets 0 to 10 points on a published scale.
  2. A group's score is the average of its criteria, converted to 0 to 100.
  3. The total is the sum of the group scores, each multiplied by its weight (0 to 100, one decimal place).
  4. Ties are broken by the higher score in the most heavily weighted group, then the next one, then alphabetically.
  5. A ranking is only published once at least five services have been scored.

Keeping it current

Every fact has a check date. We recheck prices at least every 30 days and everything else at least every 120 days (some categories use shorter intervals). An automated check flags every exceeded interval so the fact gets rechecked. The review status of all rankings is listed on our Updates.

Labels

  • Paid link: Links that earn us a commission if you buy are marked "Paid link" right next to them. See our disclosure.
  • Owned by us: Products owned by the company behind NetMedals carry this label wherever they appear. They are scored by the same criteria.

Categories with products we own

If a category includes a product owned by the operator of NetMedals, we are a competitor there. Then these additional rules apply:

  • Criteria first: criteria, scales and weights are fixed before each round of scoring. They change only through a review, after which every service is scored again.
  • Review without seeing the scores: the criteria go through a separate review step. The reviewer sees the category, weights and criteria, but no scores or positions. It checks whether the criteria reflect what buyers care about and proposes changes. The review is done by an AI model (Claude by Anthropic) in a separate session that we commission for this. It is not an outside testing organization and does not test products.
  • Later changes: criteria change only through a new review. The reviewer receives no proposed changes, including none from us, only the category, weights and criteria. Its recommendation then applies to all services alike.
  • Same evidence: products we own are scored only on publicly visible information, like every other service. An improvement counts only once it is publicly documented.
  • On record: we record every change to criteria with its date and reason.

Report an error

Is something wrong or out of date? Email contact@netmedals.com. Providers can ask us to correct facts, but cannot buy or negotiate a score.

Criteria by category