Accounting Software compared

Last reviewed: · 5 services rated

Accounting software sends invoices, pulls in bank transactions, matches receipts and prepares tax reporting. We score online services for freelancers and small businesses against published criteria, with emphasis on features such as sales tax and 1099 handling, price and plan limits. Every score links to a source and a check date. Compliance statements are reported only as the provider documents them; this is not tax advice.

  1. Rank 1:

    Zoho Books

    91.0 / 100

    For small businesses under $50K revenue that want a free plan, or a low-cost plan with phone support.

    from $15.00 / month (billed annually)

  2. Rank 2:

    Wave

    84.8 / 100

    For freelancers and very small businesses that want free invoicing and bookkeeping to start.

    from $15.83 / month (billed annually)

  3. Rank 3:

    QuickBooks Online

    80.8 / 100

    For small businesses whose accountant already works in QuickBooks.

    from $38.00 / month

All services compared

  1. Rank 1

    Zoho Books

    Free plan

    Accounting software from Zoho with a free plan, automatic sales tax, 1099 e-filing and bank feeds from the Standard plan.

    91.0 / 100
    from $15.00 / month (billed annually)
    Visit site (Zoho Books)
    Details on Zoho Books

    Scores by area

    Features (35 %)100.0
    Value for money (20 %)70.0
    Privacy & security (15 %)80.0
    Ease of use (15 %)100.0
    Fairness & support (15 %)100.0

    Best suited for: For small businesses under $50K revenue that want a free plan, or a low-cost plan with phone support.

    Strengths

    • Free plan for businesses with up to $50K revenue per year
    • Automatic sales tax (powered by Avalara) and 1099 e-filing
    • Email, voice and chat support from the Standard plan
    • Read-only access to data after cancelling, per help center

    Weaknesses

    • Standard plan capped at 5,000 invoices and 5,000 expenses per year
    • Bank feeds only from the Standard plan
    • Data of accounts inactive for more than 120 days is deleted

    Details on Zoho Books →

  2. Rank 2

    Wave

    Free plan

    Accounting and invoicing software with a free Starter plan and a Pro plan that adds bank feeds, receipt scanning and payment reminders.

    84.8 / 100
    from $15.83 / month (billed annually)
    Visit site (Wave)
    Details on Wave

    Scores by area

    Features (35 %)80.0
    Value for money (20 %)86.7
    Privacy & security (15 %)80.0
    Ease of use (15 %)100.0
    Fairness & support (15 %)83.3

    Best suited for: For freelancers and very small businesses that want free invoicing and bookkeeping to start.

    Strengths

    • Free Starter plan with unlimited invoices, estimates and bookkeeping records
    • Live chat and email support on the Pro plan
    • Annual third-party PCI DSS Level 1 audit, per provider

    Weaknesses

    • Automatic bank imports only on the Pro plan
    • Sales tax features, 1099 filing and two-factor sign-in not verified on pages open to automated checks

    Details on Wave →

  3. Rank 3

    QuickBooks Online

    Free plan

    Intuit's cloud accounting software with invoicing, automatic sales tax, bank feeds and phone support from the Simple Start plan.

    80.8 / 100
    from $38.00 / month
    Visit site (QuickBooks Online)
    Details on QuickBooks Online

    Scores by area

    Features (35 %)90.0
    Value for money (20 %)36.7
    Privacy & security (15 %)80.0
    Ease of use (15 %)100.0
    Fairness & support (15 %)100.0

    Best suited for: For small businesses whose accountant already works in QuickBooks.

    Strengths

    • Automatic sales tax calculation and Sales Tax Liability Report
    • Recurring invoices, automated reminders and pay-by-link invoices
    • Phone support on paid plans; two accountant users on Simple Start
    • Read-only access to data for one year after cancelling

    Weaknesses

    • Simple Start costs $38 per month after the introductory discount
    • 1099 e-filing via Contractor Payments add-on or the Advanced plan
    • Free plan limited to 2 invoices per month and 1 bank account

    Details on QuickBooks Online →

  4. Rank 4

    Xero

    Cloud accounting software with unlimited users, automatic sales tax, 1099 tracking and document capture in all plans.

    76.5 / 100
    from $27.00 / month
    Visit site (Xero)
    Details on Xero

    Scores by area

    Features (35 %)92.5
    Value for money (20 %)33.3
    Privacy & security (15 %)80.0
    Ease of use (15 %)100.0
    Fairness & support (15 %)70.0

    Best suited for: For small businesses that work with an accountant and want unlimited users at no extra cost.

    Strengths

    • No per-user license fees
    • Sales tax calculated automatically by location (Avalara) with sales tax reports
    • MFA with Xero Verify or other authenticator apps

    Weaknesses

    • Early plan capped at 20 invoices and 5 bills per month
    • 1099 e-filing only through partner apps or a CSV export
    • After cancellation the organization is archived and data is no longer available without paying again

    Details on Xero →

  5. Rank 5

    Invoicing-focused accounting software with automated reminders, recurring invoices and double-entry reports from the Plus plan.

    72.4 / 100
    from $20.70 / month (billed annually)
    Visit site (FreshBooks)
    Details on FreshBooks

    Scores by area

    Features (35 %)80.0
    Value for money (20 %)43.3
    Privacy & security (15 %)80.0
    Ease of use (15 %)75.0
    Fairness & support (15 %)83.3

    Best suited for: For freelancers and service businesses that bill a small number of clients.

    Strengths

    • Recurring invoices, automated late payment reminders and card/ACH payments on all plans
    • 30-day free trial without a credit card, 30-day money-back guarantee
    • Automatic bank import on all plans

    Weaknesses

    • Lite plan limited to 5 billable clients
    • Accountant access, bank reconciliation and receipt data capture only from Plus
    • No automatic sales tax calculation or 1099 filing found

    Details on FreshBooks →

Scores by area

Rank Service Features
35 %
Value for money
20 %
Privacy & security
15 %
Ease of use
15 %
Fairness & support
15 %
Score Price from
1 Zoho Books 100.070.080.0100.0100.0 91.0 from $15.00 / month (billed annually)
2 Wave 80.086.780.0100.083.3 84.8 from $15.83 / month (billed annually)
3 QuickBooks Online 90.036.780.0100.0100.0 80.8 from $38.00 / month
4 Xero 92.533.380.0100.070.0 76.5 from $27.00 / month
5 FreshBooks 80.043.380.075.083.3 72.4 from $20.70 / month (billed annually)

Prices in US dollars before sales tax, as listed by the provider for the US. Prices may change; promotional prices may differ.

Criteria and weights

Every score relies on a source. Group score = average of its criteria, total = weighted sum (0–100).

With accounting software, the feature set decides whether you can run invoicing, banking and tax work in it, so features count 35% instead of 30%. Privacy and security count 15% instead of 20% because providers differ less there than in features and plan limits.

Features Weight: 35 %

Invoicing and estimates

Which of these features does at least one plan you can buy online offer: quotes or estimates, recurring invoices, automatic payment reminders, online payment of the invoice via a link (e.g. card or ACH)?

  • 10: All four
  • 7: Three of them
  • 4: Two of them
  • 2: Invoices, but at most one of these features
  • 0: No invoicing, or not verified

Tax features

Which of the four tax features for the market does at least one plan you can buy online offer? US market: automatic sales tax calculation on invoices by location; sales tax liability report; tracking of 1099 contractor payments; e-filing of 1099 forms from within the software. DE market: creating e-invoices as XRechnung or ZUGFeRD; receiving and displaying incoming e-invoices; filing the VAT advance return via ELSTER; filing the cash-basis income statement (Anlage EÜR) or e-balance sheet via ELSTER.

  • 10: All four
  • 7: Three of them
  • 4: Two of them
  • 2: One of them
  • 0: None, or not verified

Bank feeds and receipts

Does at least one plan you can buy online offer automatic bank feeds, automatic match suggestions or rules for transactions, and receipt capture via app or email with automatic text recognition?

  • 10: All three
  • 6: Two of them
  • 3: One of them
  • 0: None, or not verified

Bookkeeping and reports

Does at least one plan you can buy online support both ways of reporting: cash-basis reports (DE market: Einnahmenüberschussrechnung) and accrual-basis reports with a balance sheet (DE market: double-entry bookkeeping with balance sheet and income statement)?

  • 10: Both
  • 5: Only one of the two
  • 0: Not verified

Value for money Weight: 20 %

Price

What is the regular monthly price, with annual billing and after any introductory discount, of the cheapest paid plan that lets you send invoices and connect a bank account (monthly price if there is no annual billing; US: USD before sales tax)?

  • 10: Up to 10.00
  • 8: Up to 15.00
  • 6: Up to 20.00
  • 4: Up to 30.00
  • 2: Up to 45.00
  • 0: Over 45.00, or not verified

Plan limits

Does the plan rated under Price have fixed caps, for example on the number of invoices, clients, receipts, bank accounts, users or revenue?

  • 10: No caps other than a single user
  • 6: One cap (e.g. invoices per month or revenue per year)
  • 3: Two or more caps
  • 0: Limits not verified

Free plan and trial

Is there a permanently free plan, or at least a free trial?

  • 10: Permanently free with invoicing and bookkeeping (income and expenses)
  • 6: Permanently free, but invoicing only or heavily limited
  • 3: Free trial of at least 14 days
  • 0: Neither, or not verified

Privacy & security Weight: 15 %

Account protection

Can sign-in be protected with a second factor via an authenticator app or security key?

  • 10: Authenticator app or security key
  • 5: Only a code by SMS or email
  • 0: No second factor, or not verified

Third-party audits

Has a named auditor certified or examined the provider or the software (e.g. ISO 27001, SOC 2, BSI C5, or a German IDW PS 880 software attestation), and is the certificate, report or attestation publicly available?

  • 10: Yes, document publicly available
  • 6: Audit or certification per provider, document not public (e.g. on request only)
  • 3: Only the data center or hosting provider is certified
  • 0: Not verified

Ease of use Weight: 15 %

Mobile apps

Are there iOS and Android apps that let you create invoices and capture receipts?

  • 10: iOS and Android, each with invoices and receipts
  • 5: Only one system, or only part of the features (e.g. receipts only)
  • 0: No app, or not verified

Working with your accountant

Can you invite your accountant or bookkeeper as a separate user at no extra cost, and can you export the ledger in a format your accountant can use (US: a file for common accounting programs, CSV or Excel; DE: DATEV format)?

  • 10: Both
  • 5: Only one of the two
  • 0: Not verified

Fairness & support Weight: 15 %

Term and cancellation

Is there a plan you can cancel month to month, and can you cancel the subscription online in your account?

  • 10: Month to month and cancel online
  • 5: Only one of the two
  • 0: Not verified

Data after cancellation

After cancelling, can you still access your records and receipts (read-only access or an archive plan), or is only an export before cancelling described?

  • 10: Read-only access or archive plan after cancellation documented
  • 5: Only an export before cancelling, or temporary access under one year, documented
  • 0: Not verified

Customer support

Can customers on the cheapest paid plan reach staff by phone or live chat in the market language, or only in writing?

  • 10: Phone or live chat with staff
  • 6: Email, form or ticket only (possibly with a chatbot)
  • 3: Help pages or forum only
  • 0: Not verified

Frequently asked questions

Do I need accounting software as a freelancer?

No specific software is required. You do need complete records of income and expenses, you must keep receipts, and depending on your situation you may need to collect and report sales tax and file 1099s. Accounting software automates much of this, such as pulling in bank transactions and preparing reports for your tax return.

What is an e-invoice?

An e-invoice is an invoice in a structured data format that software can read, not just a PDF. Some countries, such as Germany, require businesses to use them for invoices between companies. In the US there is no general e-invoicing requirement for private businesses at the time of review.

What is the difference between cash-basis and accrual accounting?

Cash-basis accounting records income when money arrives and expenses when you pay them. Accrual-basis accounting records them when you send an invoice or receive a bill. Many small businesses can use the cash method for taxes; your accountant can tell you which applies to you.

What does a third-party audit tell me about the software?

Certifications such as ISO 27001 or a SOC 2 report cover how the provider protects data and runs its systems. They do not confirm that your books are correct; you remain responsible for your records and tax filings.

Can my accountant work in the software?

Most programs let you invite your accountant as a user or export your books in a format they can import. Ask your accountant which software and access they prefer before you switch.

What happens to my data if I cancel?

The IRS generally expects you to keep records for at least three years, longer in some cases. Some providers keep read-only access after you cancel, while others ask you to export everything first. Check this before you sign up.

Related categories