Messaging Apps compared
A messaging app sends text, voice messages, photos and calls over the internet, one-on-one or in groups. We compare apps using publicly verifiable information, with emphasis on encryption, sign-up data and contact access, platforms and features. We rate personal use. We do not score how many of your contacts already use an app, because popularity never counts toward scores, and this version does not measure call or delivery quality.
- Rank 1:
88.9 / 100
People who want to pay once and use an account with no phone number at all.
one-time $6.99
- Rank 2:
88.3 / 100
People who want to share little data and hide their phone number from contacts.
free
- Rank 3:
83.9 / 100
People who want an account without a phone number and chats only with accepted contacts.
free
All services compared
- Rank 1
Paid messaging app from Switzerland that works without a phone number or email address, with open source code.
Details on Threema
Scores by area
- Features 87.5
- Value for money 80.0
- Privacy & security 100.0
- Ease of use 73.3
- Fairness & support 86.7
Strengths
- Account without a phone number, contacts by ID or QR code
- Open source code, desktop app review in 2024
- Transparency report with figures on government requests
Weaknesses
- One-time price of $6.99 (App Store) or $7.49 (Google Play)
- Chat history moves only within the same operating system
- Desktop app without the phone only in beta; no second phone or tablet
- Rank 2
Signal
Free planNonprofit, open-source messaging app with end-to-end encryption for everything and no ads.
Details on Signal
Scores by area
- Features 100.0
- Value for money 100.0
- Privacy & security 85.0
- Ease of use 86.7
- Fairness & support 70.0
Strengths
- Apps for all five platforms, linked devices with their own message queue
- No ads; per the App Store only the phone number is collected, not linked
- Encrypted backups and moves between iOS and Android
- Publishes every government request individually
Weaknesses
- Phone number required to sign up
- Account data export not verified in an accessible source
- Rank 3
Wire
Free planSwiss messaging app with end-to-end encryption for everything; personal accounts by email without a phone number.
Details on Wire
Scores by area
- Features 90.0
- Value for money 100.0
- Privacy & security 92.5
- Ease of use 56.7
- Fairness & support 70.0
Strengths
- Sign up with an email address, search by username
- Messages, files and calls always encrypted
- Transparency report with figures
Weaknesses
- Free tier without conference calls of more than two people
- Data export only on request
- Help center blocks automated access, details there not checked
- Rank 4
Facebook Messenger
Free planMeta messaging app for Facebook accounts; personal chats end-to-end encrypted by default, computer use in the browser.
Details on Facebook Messenger
Scores by area
- Features 100.0
- Value for money 75.0
- Privacy & security 57.5
- Ease of use 100.0
- Fairness & support 86.7
Strengths
- Sign up with an email address instead of a phone number
- Message requests from strangers in a separate folder
- Encrypted backup with a PIN for switching devices
Weaknesses
- Ads in Messenger Stories
- Group chats not end-to-end encrypted by default
- Per the App Store, data is used for third-party advertising
- Rank 5
WhatsApp
Free planMeta-owned messaging app with end-to-end encryption for chats and calls, and apps for phone, tablet and computer.
Details on WhatsApp
Scores by area
- Features 100.0
- Value for money 75.0
- Privacy & security 60.0
- Ease of use 86.7
- Fairness & support 86.7
Strengths
- Up to four linked devices, even while the phone is offline
- Groups of up to 1,024 members, group calls with up to 32 people
- End-to-end encrypted backup and transfer between Android and iPhone
Weaknesses
- Ads in the Updates tab (Status, Channels)
- Per the App Store, data is used for third-party advertising
- Phone number required; usernames can only be reserved so far
- Rank 6
Telegram
Free planCloud-based messaging app with very large groups and channels; end-to-end encryption only in secret chats and calls.
Details on Telegram
Scores by area
- Features 100.0
- Value for money 75.0
- Privacy & security 57.5
- Ease of use 73.3
- Fairness & support 70.0
Strengths
- Any number of devices at once, even without the phone
- Groups of up to 200,000 members
- Phone number can be hidden, chats by username
Weaknesses
- Regular chats are not end-to-end encrypted; secret chats are one-on-one only
- Ads in large public channels, bots and search
- Support run by volunteers
- Rank 7
Element
Free planApp for the open Matrix network that works without a phone number, with end-to-end encryption and open source code.
Details on Element
Scores by area
- Features 75.0
- Value for money 100.0
- Privacy & security 72.5
- Ease of use 66.7
- Fairness & support 36.7
Strengths
- No phone number needed, chats by Matrix ID
- Apps for all five platforms, more devices work without the phone
- Encrypted key storage for new devices
Weaknesses
- Maximum group size not stated
- No government request report found
- Controls for strangers not documented
- Rank 8
Apple Messages (iMessage)
Free planApple's built-in messaging app on iPhone, iPad and Mac; iMessage is end-to-end encrypted, with SMS and RCS for other phones.
Details on Apple Messages (iMessage)
Scores by area
- Features 55.0
- Value for money 100.0
- Privacy & security 50.0
- Ease of use 73.3
- Fairness & support 100.0
Strengths
- Same conversations on iPhone, iPad and Mac
- Group FaceTime calls with up to 32 others
- Apple Support by phone and chat
Weaknesses
- No app for Android, Windows or Linux
- Falls back to SMS or RCS for non-Apple phones, encrypted RCS only in beta
- Maximum group size not stated by Apple
- Rank 9
Viber
Free planRakuten messaging app with end-to-end encryption for one-on-one and group chats, funded by ads.
Details on Viber
Scores by area
- Features 87.5
- Value for money 50.0
- Privacy & security 35.0
- Ease of use 36.7
- Fairness & support 86.7
Strengths
- Apps for all five platforms
- You can set who may add you to groups
- Report with figures on government requests (EU)
Weaknesses
- Ads in the chat list
- Per the App Store, data is used to track you
- Backups on iCloud or Google Drive are not end-to-end encrypted
- Rank 10
Google Messages
Free planGoogle's messaging app for Android using RCS and SMS; RCS chats between Google Messages users are end-to-end encrypted.
Details on Google Messages
Scores by area
- Features 32.5
- Value for money 100.0
- Privacy & security 35.0
- Ease of use 63.3
- Fairness & support 60.0
Strengths
- RCS chats between Google Messages users encrypted by default
- Use on a computer through Messages for web
- Block and report spam in one step
Weaknesses
- No app for iPhone
- Phone must stay on and online for Messages for web
- Falls back to unencrypted SMS
Scores by area
| Rank | Service | Features | Value for money | Privacy & security | Ease of use | Fairness & support | Score | Price from |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Threema | 87.5 | 80.0 | 100.0 | 73.3 | 86.7 | 88.9 | one-time $6.99 |
| 2 | Signal | 100.0 | 100.0 | 85.0 | 86.7 | 70.0 | 88.3 | free |
| 3 | Wire | 90.0 | 100.0 | 92.5 | 56.7 | 70.0 | 83.9 | free |
| 4 | Facebook Messenger | 100.0 | 75.0 | 57.5 | 100.0 | 86.7 | 80.6 | free |
| 5 | 100.0 | 75.0 | 60.0 | 86.7 | 86.7 | 79.5 | free | |
| 6 | Telegram | 100.0 | 75.0 | 57.5 | 73.3 | 70.0 | 74.1 | free |
| 7 | Element | 75.0 | 100.0 | 72.5 | 66.7 | 36.7 | 69.6 | free |
| 8 | Apple Messages (iMessage) | 55.0 | 100.0 | 50.0 | 73.3 | 100.0 | 67.2 | free |
| 9 | Viber | 87.5 | 50.0 | 35.0 | 36.7 | 86.7 | 57.6 | free |
| 10 | Google Messages | 32.5 | 100.0 | 35.0 | 63.3 | 60.0 | 48.9 | free |
Criteria and weights
Every score relies on a source. Group score = average of its criteria, total = weighted sum (0–100).
Privacy and security count 35 instead of 20 %, features 25 instead of 30 % and value 10 instead of 20 %. A messaging app carries private conversations, and consumer groups and government security agencies name encryption and how an app handles your phone number and contacts as the key differences. Most messaging apps are free for personal use, so price barely separates them.
Features Weight: 25 %
Platforms
- 10: All five platforms
- 7: iOS and Android, one computer platform missing
- 4: iOS and Android, two or three computer platforms missing
- 2: iOS only or Android only
- 0: Not verified
Multiple devices
- 10: Computer and tablet in addition, even with the phone turned off
- 5: Additional devices only with limits (phone must be online, only one extra device, or computer only or tablet only)
- 0: One device per account only, or not verified
Voice and video calls
- 10: Voice and video, one-on-one and in groups
- 6: Voice and video one-on-one, groups voice only or not at all
- 3: Voice calls only
- 0: No calls, or not verified
Group size
- 10: 250 or more
- 7: 100 to 249
- 4: 30 to 99
- 2: Fewer than 30
- 0: No group chats, or not verified
Value for money Weight: 10 %
Cost
- 10: Free
- 8: One-time up to 6.00
- 6: One-time up to 12.00, or subscription up to 1.00 per month
- 3: One-time over 12.00, or subscription up to 3.00 per month
- 0: Subscription over 3.00 per month, or not verified
Ads
- 10: No ads
- 5: Ads only outside chats and the chat list (for example status or channels)
- 0: Ads in chats or the chat list, or not verified
Privacy & security Weight: 35 %
End-to-end encryption
- 10: On by default for one-on-one and group chats and calls, with no unencrypted fallback
- 6: On by default, but with gaps (for example groups, calls, SMS fallback, or only between certain devices)
- 3: Only when turned on, for example as a secret chat
- 0: No end-to-end encryption, or not verified
Phone number and contacts
- 10: No phone number required, and new chats without contact access
- 7: Phone number required but can be hidden from contacts, and new chats without contact access
- 4: Only one of these: number cannot be hidden, or new chats only with contact access or invite links
- 0: Number cannot be hidden and new chats need contact access, or not verified
Data use per app store labels
- 10: No advertising use, no tracking; at most contact info, contacts and identifiers linked to you
- 6: No advertising use, no tracking, but more data linked to you (for example usage data, location, diagnostics)
- 3: Data used for the provider's or third-party ads, but no tracking and no sharing with third parties for ads
- 0: Tracking (App Store) or sharing with third parties for ads (Google Play), or not verified
Source code and security audit
- 10: Public source code and a third-party audit in the last 36 months
- 7: One of the two
- 4: Only a technical description of the encryption (white paper), or an audit older than 36 months
- 0: None of these, or not verified
Ease of use Weight: 15 %
Backup and switching phones
- 10: Transfer between iOS and Android and an encrypted backup
- 6: Exactly one of these: transfer between iOS and Android without an encrypted backup, or an encrypted backup with transfer within the same system only
- 3: Transfer within the same system only, with no backup or only an unencrypted one
- 0: No chat history transfer, or not verified
Protection from strangers
- 10: All three
- 6: Two of the three
- 3: One of the three
- 0: None of these, or not verified
Language
- 10: App, help center and privacy policy
- 5: App in the market language, but not the help center or privacy policy
- 0: No app interface in the market language, or not verified
Fairness & support Weight: 15 %
Account deletion and data export
- 10: Self-service deletion and self-service export of chats or account data
- 5: Self-service deletion, export only on request or not documented
- 0: Deletion only on request, or not verified
Government request report
- 10: Report with figures or individual requests, at most 24 months old
- 5: Report older than 24 months, or without figures
- 0: No report, or not verified
Customer support
- 10: Live chat with staff or phone
- 6: Email or form only, including in the app (possibly with a chatbot)
- 3: Help pages or forum only
- 0: Not verified
Frequently asked questions
What does end-to-end encryption mean for messaging apps?
Messages are encrypted on your device and only decrypted on the recipient's device, so the provider cannot read them. Encryption does not protect metadata, such as who messages whom and when, and cloud backups are not encrypted the same way by every service.
Why don't you score how many people use an app?
A messaging app is only useful if your contacts use it too. Which app that is depends on the people around you, and popularity never counts toward our scores. That is why many people use two or more messaging apps side by side.
Why does access to my contacts matter?
Many messaging apps match the phone numbers in your contacts against their servers to show who already uses the app. This also sends numbers of people who do not use the service. Some apps also work without that access, for example through usernames, IDs or QR codes.
What happens when I send an SMS or RCS message?
SMS goes through your carrier and is not end-to-end encrypted. RCS, the successor to SMS, supports end-to-end encryption depending on the device, app and carrier. Look for the lock icon or the notice in the app that shows whether a conversation is encrypted.
How do I switch apps without losing touch with people?
Install the new app alongside the old one and tell your contacts how to reach you there. Save important chats before you remove the old app. If you stop using a service, delete the account in the app rather than just uninstalling it.